This article is written by Leela Madhuri of 9th semester of BA.LLB of G.S.K.M Law College affiliated with Adikavi Nannya University, an intern under Legal Vidhiya.
Abstract:
Navigating religious laws in conjunction with criminal justice systems may be difficult, particularly in developing nations where such norms are deeply rooted in traditions and heavily relied on by the people. These acts of violence are often used for control or influence, resulting in aggressive community outbursts and the involvement of government authorities. Conflicts between religious laws and modern criminal justice procedures can lead to misunderstandings and inconsistencies. However, it is critical to recognize the importance and applicability of religious norms in various parts of the world and navigate them carefully to avoid unnecessary challenges. In this article, we will explore this intersection in depth, discussing the various challenges that arise when religious laws and criminal laws collide in developing nations.
Keywords:
Religious Laws, Crimes, Developing Nations, Religious freedom, Legal systems, Human rights, Legal challenges, International perspectives.
Introduction:
Religious laws and crimes are essential features of legal frameworks in developing nations worldwide. These rules, especially those frequently derived from holy texts and teachings, control different elements of people’s lives, such as personal behavior, familial issues, and community conventions. These rules are firmly established in religious beliefs and traditions, influencing believers’ ethical standards and actions. Understanding the complicated subject of religious laws and crimes is critical for navigating worldwide. Religious laws and institutions can result in crimes, violations, and consequences that can be harsh both legally and socially, emphasizing the need to follow these rules. Understanding religious laws is critical in developing countries because religion influences social customs and legal frameworks. However, the intersection of religious laws with human rights and constitutional principles can create challenges, as conflicts may arise between religious freedoms and individual rights. Understanding these rules is beneficial because it enables a glimpse at how spiritual texts are used within legal systems. This article addresses religious laws and crimes in developing countries, as well as debates and suggested approaches to these complicated concerns.
The concept of religious laws:
Religion has an immense impact on the legal systems of developing countries worldwide since their rich cultural history and spiritual practices profoundly influence how crimes are classified, judged, and penalized, demonstrating religion’s substantial contribution to the community. In India, individual norms are based on religion and community. Citizens can select between these personal laws and counterpart secular norms. Hindu law, Muslim law, and Christian law were all codified and revised to various levels. It is clear that law and religion are inseparable and that religion plays a significant part in sustaining legality in traditional society structures worldwide. The main aspects of religious laws include legal pluralism, where developing nations recognize and incorporate religious laws alongside their secular systems. Religion has historically served as the foundation for the creation of laws, from the past to the present, and law and religion overlap as concepts [1]. This recognition provides power to religious communities to control topics like divorce, marriage, heirlooms, and individual social standing, separating them from Western countries with primarily secular laws. Religious law directs people’s beliefs and actions, whereas secular law tackles external effects on others. Religious law frequently overlaps with secular norms because it is concerned with causing harm to others rather than disturbing someone else [2]. Managing religious freedom and individual rights is an ongoing challenge for developing countries, as the combination of religious laws and national legal systems can lead to disputes and challenges, particularly on the subjects of human rights and the consideration of religious minorities. Understanding religious diversity in societies is crucial for navigating legal diversity and balancing religious laws with human rights, cultural traditions, and evolving needs in modern society.
Let us see some relevant laws to understand more.
Hindu law is a vital legal system in Hinduism that deals with family, marriage, inheritance, and rituals. It was initially primarily established in India, which has a substantial Hindu population. The Hindu Marriage Act and Hindu Succession Act are important legislation in Hindu law that control marriage, inheritance, family problems, religious practices, and the caste system. The Hindu Marriage Act of 1955 governs marriage, divorce, and maintenance, while the Hindu Succession Act of 1956 provides gender equality in property rights. These laws also cover family issues, religious practices, and social and economic life in Hindu-majority countries.
Muslim law, an integral component of Islamic law, covers several aspects of Muslim life, such as family affairs, personal behavior, and economic transactions, and plays a crucial part in developing nations. The Islamic Marriage Contract (Nikah) governs family and marriage, inheritance, criminal law, and personal conduct. It handles concerns such as polygamy, maintenance, and child custody, as well as establishing their shares. Sharia-based criminal laws may apply in Muslim-majority countries.
Christian law, also known as Canon Law, oversees church life and clergy behavior, particularly in developing countries with a substantial religious presence, impacting religious and civil affairs. Canon Law is a legal book that describes the ordinances, hierarchical government, ceremonies, property of churches, and penal law within the Catholic Church. It specifies the conditions for marriage, obstacles, and divorce procedures, and it may have legal ramifications in civil law systems. However, its applicability in civil concerns differs by nation, with some countries having agreements between the Church and the state on subjects like marriage and education.
Understanding the role of religion in developing nations Crimes Related to Religious Practices:
Religion plays a significant role in shaping the values and beliefs of society, shaping personal choices, family structures, and legal frameworks. It shapes the social, cultural, and political fabric of developing nations. Understanding the importance of religion in developing countries involves a study of historical and cultural environments. Religion has a role in molding civilizations and functioning as a combining factor. Hindu countries such as India and Nepal recognize Hindu individual rules based on ancient scriptures known as Dharmashastras. Among the Hindu community, these customs regulate issues like marriage, divorce, and adoption. Islamic law, also known as Sharia law, is widely practiced in countries such as Saudi Arabia and Iran, and it governs family disputes, criminal offenses, and business transactions. In contrast, the implementation and execution of Sharia law may differ between places and sects within Islam. Other religions, such as Buddhism, Sikhism, and Christianity, have their religious laws that handle individual status, religious ceremonies, and cultural practices unique to their faiths. Religion lowers crime rates dramatically, especially in firmly promoted cultures. Despite government efforts, religious practices appear to be wildly effective in suppressing crime rates in countries [3]. Religious laws in developing nations represent cultural customs and spiritual diversity, ensuring a careful balance of human rights, cultural traditions, and changing requirements. Legal disparities and different religious legal frameworks are critical in negotiating the intersection of religious laws and crimes while establishing an appropriate balance of rights and cultural traditions.
The influence of religion on social norms and morals in developing nations:
Religion, values, and morality are the foundations on which society’s essential moral ideals are built. Such common beliefs demonstrate the importance, admiration, and respect to which critical values are accorded. They are accepted as legitimate views and norms for society’s stability [4]. Religion has a significant impact in defining societal norms and values in developing countries, affecting the judicial system and cultural background of shaping the view and handling of crimes based on convictions. Religion offers a moral guide, influencing people’s perceptions of relationships, family structures, gender roles, and what is good and wrong. Its lessons can also be incorporated into the legal framework, directly affecting laws and shaping the judicial system. Understanding the cultural context and the effect of religion is critical for managing the connection between religious rules and crimes in developing countries. Different religions see crime and punishment differently. Religious figures possess considerable social power, settling conflicts, offering advice, and influencing judicial procedures, resulting in a complicated interplay in which customs and practices intersect with state laws. Although religious rules and beliefs play a significant role in society, they should not be used to allow prejudice or infringing on human rights. An equitable and open judiciary that upholds religious beliefs and justice principles is required, which requires coordination among legislatures, non-governmental organizations, and religious leaders. Understanding the cultural context is critical for defending the rights and dignity of all people, regardless of religion. Transparent discussion, education, and the development of a safe environment are essential for attaining this aim.
Examining the relevance of human rights in religious laws and offenses:
Religious laws shape cultural norms and legal systems, impacting human rights. However, these laws must be consistent with globally recognized human rights norms, particularly in developing countries where cultural norms are frequently complicated and sensitive. Religious diversity and cultural variety are intertwined, and religions have a big part to play in safeguarding and advancing human rights. However, particular religions may not actively protect these rights, leading to disputes and obsessive notions [5]. International treaties offer a global foundation for protecting human rights, assuring their preservation and protection. Nevertheless, it is critical to analyze if religious legislation in developing countries successfully protects these ideals or potentially infringes on them. Religious views can sometimes justify human rights violations such as discrimination and violence, emphasizing the need for a balance between religious liberty and human rights protection, assuring the safety of all persons. Religious beliefs contribute a substantial part to human rights protection. However, they possess an obligation to offer equal protection for all persons, making the complicated task of balancing religious freedom with human rights difficult. International human rights organizations and legal scholars take a crucial part in campaigns on safeguards of human rights in the context of religious legislation, creating an ideal balance between beliefs and human rights commitments. This analysis can help develop legal frameworks that uphold religious freedom and human rights, addressing the challenges faced by these groups.
The role of international organizations in the implementation of religious laws and crimes:
International organizations play an important role in worldwide efforts to promote religious freedom and oppose prejudice, especially in developing countries where religious diversity frequently coexists with socioeconomic and political issues. Their activities are critical in fostering pluralism while advertising for human rights. The United Nations (UN) is a well-known international organization that combats religious prejudice and violence through its different departments, notably the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) and the Human Rights Council [6]. The UN builds guidelines for member states, promotes discussion between religious communities, and funds activities that promote understanding and respect among varied religious groups. Religious freedom is a fundamental component of society, and the UN’s Personal Representative on Freedom of Religion examines complaints and reports on religious freedom throughout the globe. Religious groups such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch seek to protect human rights and prevent religious prejudice. They cooperate with local activists and regional organizations to understand international human rights norms, establish precedents, and promote legal frameworks for religious minorities. International organizations seek to promote religious freedom and preserve people’s rights to practice their faith without fear of discrimination or violence. However, issues remain in developing nations, which need collaboration and sharing of knowledge to solve religious legislation and offenses.
Analyzing the difficulties dealing with religious laws in developing nations:
Religious laws in developing countries display complicated relationships between religion, culture, and legal systems, with religious laws having a considerable impact on social norms and governance, posing particular problems in managing these complex legal environments. Religious diversity poses significant issues, such as disputes and violence. Multiple religious communities can exist in nations, causing conflicts and prejudice. To minimize violence and guarantee that all people have equal rights, it is essential to establish an agreement between religious freedom and equality. Religious laws hold considerable influence in developing nations, affecting the judiciary. Inconsistencies and prejudices can, however, occur, needing a balance between religious liberty, upholding universal human rights norms, and providing a fair and reasonable implementation of justice. Religion laws are frequently challenged owing to the power of religious leaders and their congregations. These leaders may regard laws that violate their views as unjust, making it difficult for judicial institutions to implement them. Addressing gender-related crimes within religious regulations remains a delicate topic, as traditional practices may sustain discrimination and violence against women. Religious freedom is a crucial component of human rights, and tackling these difficulties necessitates open communication and collaboration among legal systems, religious leaders, researchers, and communities to establish common ground and assure justice and equality. Religious laws and crimes in developing countries are complicated topics that must be carefully considered concerning cultural, social, and legal factors. Addressing these issues can help create a more equal and open society.
Related Case Laws:
- Asia Bibi blasphemy case [7]:
Pakistan’s severe blasphemy laws have been used to harass religious minorities. Asia Bibi, a Christian woman who received the death penalty for blasphemy against Islam, is a famous case. This prominent case received international attention, shedding light on the abuse of these regulations.
- Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala [8]:
This is a landmark Indian constitutional case in which three students refused to perform the national anthem owing to religious beliefs. The Supreme Court decided that the school officials’ conduct infringed on their basic rights, adding that there are no statutes mandating pupils, regardless of their beliefs, to sing the anthem.
- Shafin Jahan v/s Asokan K.M [9]:
In India, religious law rules marriage, and a Hindu woman’s conversion to Islam resulted in litigation. Hadiya, originally Akhila Ashokan, married Muslim Shafin Jahan. Her parents accused her of being coerced into conversion. The Kerala High Court invalidated their marriage in 2017, but the Supreme Court affirmed her freedom to choose her religion and partner in 2018.
- Raqqa Stoning Case [10]:
Religious laws were firmly enforced by the ISIS leadership in Raqqa, Syria, including penalties such as stoning for alleged adultery. In 2014, a lady called Rania was stoned to death in Raqqa, demonstrating severe cruelty and human rights violations under ISIS’ interpretation of religious law.
Recommendations:
Mutual understanding and respect for religious views are critical in promoting tolerance and protection of varied religious groups, especially in developing countries. This understanding helps the resolution of disagreements and protects the preservation of people’s privileges despite religious affiliation. Second, while religious freedom is essential in numerous cultures, it should not be used to violate individual rights or perpetuate prejudice. Legal systems in developing countries should provide clear frameworks that maintain core human rights principles while allowing for legitimate religious practices. Furthermore, international organizations and human rights activists play a substantial part in assisting developing countries in navigating religious laws and offenses, including offering technical help, capacity development, and fostering conversation for fair and inclusive legal systems. Legal professionals study case laws to gain valuable insights, conducting in-depth analyses of past cases to identify areas requiring reform or interpretation. This research assists in formulating comprehensive legal frameworks that effectively balance religious freedom, human rights, and the rule of law.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, religious laws play a critical part in developing human values and establishing a harmonic ratio on a sociopolitical level, as they lead the growth and advancement of these nations, safeguarding their religious identity and fundamental human rights. Religious laws are necessary for society to grow, but they must protect individuals’ rights and liberties. Acceptance and pluralism must be promoted via transparent and welcoming conversations. Developing countries must prioritize human rights and create legal frameworks that protect the well-being and dignity of all people, irrespective of religious views. This creates an environment where people can freely practice their faith without fear of violence or prejudice. Understanding culture is an obstacle in developing countries because the interaction of religious legislation and crimes is complicated. Striking a balance between religious legislation and the criminal justice system is critical for maintaining justice, equality, and respect for individual liberties. One might work towards a future where religious views are honored, human rights are preserved, and justice is achieved by encouraging discourse, understanding, and campaigning for legislative reforms.
References:
- Religious Law Overview & Purpose
https://study.com/academy/lesson/religious-law-definition-purpose.html
- Religion and Crime
- Religious Law And Crime In Developing/Developed Nations
https://peachyessay.com/sample-essay/religious-law-and-crime-in-developing-developed-nations/
- HOW RELIGION INFLUENCES BEHAVIOUR
https://www.monkprayogshala.in/blog/2016/5/15/how-religion-influences-behaviour-1
- Religion and human rights
- Article 9: Freedom of thought, belief and religion
- 2021 Report on International Religious Freedom: India
https://www.state.gov/reports/2021-report-on-international-religious-freedom/india/
[1] Law and Religion, https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/1852/Law-and-Religion.html (Last visited on 27 September 2023).
[2] Religious Law: Meaning & Examples, https://www.tutorialspoint.com/religious-law-meaning-and-examples (Last visited on 27 September 2023).
[3] Religious Crime And Religious Laws In Developed And Developing Countries, https://ijcrt.org/papers/IJCRT2210076.pdf (Last visited on 27 September 2023).
[4] Impact Of Religion On Societal Value Development, file:///C:/Users/chlma/Downloads/1685-Article%20Text-5488-1-10-20211125.pdf (Last visited on 28 September 2023).
[5] Human Rights And Religions, https://rm.coe.int/16806f546c (Last visited on 28 September 2023).
[6] Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_the_United_Nations_High_Commissioner_for_Human_Rights (Last visited on 28 September 2023).
[7] A Critical Review of Asia Bibi Case, https://sahsol.lums.edu.pk/node/12860 (Last visited on 28 September 2023).
[8] BIJOE EMMANUEL V. STATE OF KERALA AND ORS [A.I.R 1987 SC 748], https://legalvidhiya.com/bijoe-emmanuel-v-state-of-kerala-and-ors-a-i-r-1987-sc-748/ (Last visited on 28 September 2023).
[9] Hadiya Marriage Case: Shafin Jahan v/s Asokan K.M, https://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-9531-hadiya-marriage-case-shafin-jahan-v-s-asokan-k-m.html (Last visited on 28 September 2023).
[10] Women stoned to death in Syria for adultery, https://english.alarabiya.net/perspective/features/2014/08/09/Women-stoned-to-death-in-Syria-for-adultery (Last visited on 28 September 2023).
0 Comments