THE ROLE OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS IN PROMOTING INNOVATION IN INDIA

This article is written by Deepika Kapoor of Dr. Ram Manohar Lohiya National Law University, an intern under Legal Vidhiya

Abstract

The paper delves into the critical role of Intellectual Property Rights (I.P.R.) in fostering innovation and economic growth. It begins by highlighting the historical significance of I.P.R., tracing its roots to the Industrial Revolution in Europe. The document outlines various types of I.P.R., including patents, trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets, elucidating their unique functions in protecting creators’ rights. A historical evolution of I.P.R. laws in India is also presented, demonstrating the country’s commitment to aligning with international standards.

Furthermore, the paper explores the merits and demerits of I.P.R. It argues that while I.P.R. encourages innovation, facilitates technology transfer, and stimulates economic growth, it also poses significant challenges such as limited duration, high costs, and potential conflicts with the public interest. These challenges, if not addressed, can hinder innovation and economic growth. Despite these limitations, the protection of I.P.R. is crucial for promoting creativity and safeguarding creators’ rights.

In conclusion, the document asserts that I.P.R. is an indispensable tool for encouraging innovation and driving economic development. It calls for a balanced approach to I.P.R. protection, one that ensures creators’ rights are upheld while also safeguarding public interests and promoting fair competition.

Keywords

Intellectual Property, Intellectual Property Rights, Innovation, I.P.R. laws.

Introduction

Progress is rooted in innovation, and innovation thrives through competition. The desire to contribute something unique and valuable to society drives innovators to generate new ideas and inventions. Innovators are further motivated by the recognition and ownership they receive for their work, which fuels them to create even more. One example of this is Thomas Edison, who is widely credited with inventing the commercially viable incandescent light bulb. However, several other inventors, including Joseph Swan in the U.K., were also developing similar technology at the same time. Legal disputes over patent rights ensued, and Edison ultimately emerged victorious. Despite other inventors working on similar technology, Thomas is still recognized as the inventor of the light bulb. This underscores the importance of securing legal recognition for one’s work. Intellectual property (I.P.) is an individual’s creation, and I.P. rights (I.P.R.) are legal protections given to that creator for a designated period of time. This system ensures that creators, innovators, and inventors are rewarded for their work, which motivates them to continue creating. Legal recognition of intellectual property is critical because it provides innovators with a sense of ownership and the ability to monetize their inventions. Without legal protection, anyone could copy and sell the invention, depriving the innovators of the financial rewards they deserve. Moreover, recognition of I.P. rights allows the innovator to control how their invention is used and prevent unethical or harmful uses. In sum, recognizing intellectual property is vital for society’s continued progress. It protects the rights of creators, innovators, and inventors and motivates them to address society’s challenges with new, innovative solutions.

Importance of I.P.R. in the Current Domain

The concept of Intellectual Property Rights (I.P.R.) is one that has gained significant importance in recent years. The protection of intellectual property has become a vital tool in promoting innovation and economic growth, both at the individual and national levels. The purpose of this paper is to explore the various benefits of I.P.R. and the ways in which it contributes to the growth of the economy. One of the key advantages of I.P.R. is that it creates a belief among competitors to innovate, invent, and create new and valuable intellectual property, which can gain recognition globally. Additionally, I.P.R. encourages innovation by taking risks and exploring new areas, providing exclusive benefits and rights to use and profit from their work. By protecting their works, I.P.R. promotes competition in the market, giving inventors a complete edge in the market by preventing others from using their work or creating benefits without the original creator of that intellectual property. Furthermore, I.P.R. gives the inventor the autonomy to decide the price and marketing strategy and how they can benefit from the distribution channels. An idea can turn into a profit-making asset only when it is executed by means of intellectual property rights. Intellectual property rights help innovators turn their ideas into commercially successful products and services. Without I.P.R., there is a risk of an individual’s ideas, products, or any intellectual property being copied and stolen, demotivating the original creator. The lack of intellectual property rights can also have an impact on the economy as a whole through the theft of others’ ideas. I.P. theft can lead to significant revenue loss for the innovator, discouraging future innovation and investment in research and development. As a result, I.P.R. contributes to the growth of the economy by encouraging the production of intellectual property. It offers legal protection to innovators and inventors who wish to invest in research and development, promoting economic growth., the protection of intellectual property through I.P.R. is essential for promoting innovation and economic growth. It encourages competitors to innovate, invent, and create new and valuable intellectual property and provides exclusive benefits and rights to use and profit from their work. Additionally, I.P.R. protects the original creator from the theft of their ideas and promotes competition in the market, providing a complete edge to inventors. Therefore, I.P.R. is an indispensable tool for economic growth and should be protected and promoted.

Types of I.P.R.

Patent- A patent is a legally binding document granting an inventor the exclusive right to prevent others from producing, using, selling, or importing their invention for a specified period. This period is usually 20 years from the date the patent application was filed. The purpose of a patent is to encourage innovation by providing inventors with the exclusive right to profit from their inventions for a limited time. This allows inventors to recoup their research and development investment and profit from their creativity. At the same time, patents promote knowledge and technology sharing by requiring inventors to disclose their inventions in their patent applications fully.[1]

Trademark – A trademark is essentially a unique symbol, name, or design that identifies a particular seller’s goods or services from those of other sellers. It can be any distinct part of a brand’s identity, such as words, names, symbols, or slogans. All such elements of a brand are eligible for protection under trademark law.[2]

The term “industrial design” pertains to a functional product’s aesthetic and decorative elements, including its shape, pattern, or color. These features serve as distinctive trademarks that set apart one product from another. Two categories of intellectual property protection, namely design patents and registered design protection, are available to safeguard these industrial designs.[3]

Copyright- is a legal term that refers to the exclusive rights granted to creators of literary and artistic works. These works can be anything from books, music, paintings, sculptures, and films to computer programs, databases, advertisements, maps, and technical drawings. In other words, copyright gives creators control over the use and distribution of their original creations.

Geographical indications, or G.I.s, represent labels affixed to goods originating from a specific region to denote the unique characteristics consumers associate with that particular region. Such labels are commonly found on food items, including wine and cheese. The primary goal of G.I.s is to prevent geographical names and indicators from being used inappropriately or misused.[4]

Plant variety protection, as another form of intellectual property protection, is granted to novel plant varieties that have been developed through selective breeding or genetic manipulation. This protection grants the owner exclusive control over the production, sale, or distribution of the plant type for a specific period of time.

trade secret, as the name suggests, is defined as a piece of information that derives independent economic value; any valuable assets for any business that are confidential for a trade business can be termed as a trade secret; a trade secret is important for a business to prosper, thrive and survive and losing onto that trade secret can diminish business credibility, three important constituents of a trade secret is information that is not known to the generic public or relevant business circle something that confers an economic benefit on its owner, and the subject of reasonable efforts to maintain its secrecy.

Historical Evolution and Loss Pertaining to Intellectual Property Rights

Intellectual property rights (I.P.R.) have been around since ancient times. The current idea of intellectual property rights emerged during the Industrial Revolution in Europe. Businesspeople and inventors realized the value of their ideas and the need to protect them. England passed the first modern patent law in 1624, and the first copyright law was enacted in 1710. The Paris and Berne Conventions were the first international agreements on intellectual property. The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) was established in 1967[5] to encourage global enforcement of intellectual property rights. These rights include copyrights, trade secrets, patents, and trademarks.

The safeguarding and enforcement of the rights of artists and inventors in India is governed by a range of laws and regulations that deal with Intellectual Property Rights (I.P.R.). Some of the most significant laws relating to intellectual property rights in India are: The Patents Act of 1970[6], which governs the granting and protection of patents in India. In 2005, this legislation was amended to align it with international standards. The Trade Marks Act of 1999[7] regulates the registration and protection of trademarks in India. In 2010, this law was also modified to bring it in line with international standards. The Copyright Act of 1957[8] safeguards original works of authorship, such as books, music, and software, from being copied or reproduced without permission. The Designs Act of the year 2000[9] governs the registration and protection of industrial designs in India. The Geographical Indications of Products (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999[10] enables geographical indications to be registered and protected in India. Apart from these laws, India is a signatory to several international agreements concerning I.P.R., including the World Trade Organization’s Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) (W.T.O.).[11] Despite India’s intellectual property rights laws being modified to meet international standards, their application and enforcement are still significant issues. For example, the backlog of patent applications and the slow pace of trademark registrations being processed in India have been a cause of concern. However, the government has taken various measures to address these issues, such as increasing the number of examiners and introducing fast-track processes for certain types of applications.

Merits and Demerits of I.P.R.

Intellectual Property Rights (I.P.R.) is a term that refers to the legal rights protecting the creations of the human mind, including inventions, literary and creative works, commercial symbols, names, and images. Here are some advantages of I.P.R.: Encourages innovation: I.P.R. provides a legal framework for protecting the creations of the human mind. The protection of intellectual property rights encourages creativity by granting creators the right to possess exclusive rights to their work for a predetermined amount of time. These rights can provide creators with financial and professional benefits and public acknowledgement of their accomplishments. [12] Facilitates transfer of technology and knowledge: I.P.R. helps to facilitate the transfer of technology and expertise from developed countries to developing ones by providing a means for technology owners to license or sell their patents to other companies or governments. This allows for transferring technology and knowledge from developed countries to developing ones.  Stimulates economic growth and development: The protection of intellectual property rights can stimulate economic growth and development by providing creators with a method to monetize their creations and stimulating investment in innovative and creative endeavors.  Protects consumers: I.P.R. helps safeguard consumers by guaranteeing that the goods and services they purchase are genuine and of high quality and by preventing them from being misled or harmed by inferior products. Promotes social and cultural values: Protecting traditional knowledge, artistic expressions, and other forms of intangible heritage that are significant to communities and societies worldwide is one way that intellectual property rights (I.P.R.) can contribute to promoting social and cultural values.

Intellectual property rights (I.P.R.) have certain limitations that are important to understand. One limitation is the limited duration of protection, which depends on the type of intellectual property. Patents can be protected for a maximum of 20 years from the filling date of application[13], after which they become public property. This limited duration may discourage innovation by discouraging innovators from investing in research and development, as they may fear losing their intellectual property rights too soon. Another limitation of I.P.R. is the high cost of acquiring and enforcing these rights. This can burden individuals and small organizations, who may struggle to afford the expense of developing a patent or hiring an attorney to enforce their rights. Additionally, I.P.R. can be restricted by geography, as the rights earned in one country may not be recognized in another. This can make it difficult for businesses to protect their intellectual property globally. There can also be conflicts between intellectual property rights and the public interest. For instance, patenting a life-saving drug can drive up prices and limit access to those in need, which can be against the public’s interest. In such situations, the public interest can precede intellectual property rights. Finally, I.P.R. can be abused when major businesses use their rights to limit competition or prevent others from entering the market. This can limit consumer options and lead to higher costs for goods and services.

Conclusion

Intellectual Property Rights (I.P.R.) are instrumental in fostering innovation, protecting creators’ rights, and driving economic growth. Through legal frameworks such as patents, trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets, I.P.R. provides creators exclusive rights to their creations, incentivizing them to innovate and contribute to society. Additionally, I.P.R. facilitates the transfer of technology and knowledge, stimulates competition, and promotes economic growth.

However, I.P.R. also presents challenges, including limited duration, high costs, and potential conflicts with public interest. Despite these limitations, the protection of I.P.R. is crucial for encouraging creativity, ensuring fair competition, and safeguarding consumers’ rights. Therefore, a balanced approach to I.P.R. protection is essential, upholding creators’ rights while also considering public interests and promoting innovation for the betterment of society.

References

1. WIPO,https://www.wipo.int/patents/en/faq_patents.html#:~:text=How%20long%20does%20patent%20protection,Patents%20are%20territorial%20rights. (last visited Mar 9, 2024).
2. Dr. Madhu Bala Kaushik, Dr. Poonam Rajharia, Dr. Varsha Tiwari Vyas, & Ms. Sumedha Soni, Navigating Intellectual Property Rights: Fostering Innovation, Access, and Education in the Indian Context, E3S Web of Conferences, (Mar. 10, 2024, 9:29 PM), https://www.e3s-conferences.org/articles/e3sconf/pdf/2023/36/e3sconf_iconnect2023_07004.pdf.
3. WIPO, https://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/convention/summary_wipo_convention.html#:~:text=The%20WIPO%20Convention%2C%20the%20constituent,and%20was%20amended%20in%201979. (last visited Mar 8, 2024).
4. WTO, https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/trips_e/intel2_e.htm (last visited Mar 8, 2024).
5. WIPO, https://www.wipo.int/about-ip/en/ (last visited Mar 9, 2024).

---

[1]WIPO,https://www.wipo.int/patents/en/faq_patents.html#:~:text=How%20long%20does%20patent%20protection,Patents%20are%20territorial%20rights. (last visited Mar 9, 2024).

[2] Dr. Madhu Bala Kaushik, Dr. Poonam Rajharia, Dr. Varsha Tiwari Vyas, & Ms. Sumedha Soni, Navigating Intellectual Property Rights: Fostering Innovation, Access, and Education in the Indian Context, E3S Web of Conferences, (Mar. 10, 2024, 9:29 PM), https://www.e3s-conferences.org/articles/e3sconf/pdf/2023/36/e3sconf_iconnect2023_07004.pdf.

[3] Dr. Madhu Bala Kaushik, Dr. Poonam Rajharia, Dr. Varsha Tiwari Vyas, & Ms. Sumedha Soni, Navigating Intellectual Property Rights: Fostering Innovation, Access, and Education in the Indian Context, E3S Web of Conferences, (Mar. 10, 2024, 9:29 PM), https://www.e3s-conferences.org/articles/e3sconf/pdf/2023/36/e3sconf_iconnect2023_07004.pdf.

[4] Dr. Madhu Bala Kaushik, Dr. Poonam Rajharia, Dr. Varsha Tiwari Vyas, & Ms. Sumedha Soni, Navigating Intellectual Property Rights: Fostering Innovation, Access, and Education in the Indian Context, E3S Web of Conferences, (Mar. 10, 2024, 9:29 PM), https://www.e3s-conferences.org/articles/e3sconf/pdf/2023/36/e3sconf_iconnect2023_07004.pdf.

[5]WIPO, https://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/convention/summary_wipo_convention.html#:~:text=The%20WIPO%20Convention%2C%20the%20constituent,and%20was%20amended%20in%201979. (last visited Mar 8, 2024).

[6] The Patents Act, No. 39, Acts of Parliament, 1970 (India).

[7] The Trade Marks Act, No. 47, Acts of Parliament, 1999 (India).

[8] The Copyright Act, 1957, No. 14. Acts of Parliament, 1957(India).

[9] The Designs Act, No. 16, Acts of Parliament, 2000 (India).

[10] The Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999, No.48. Acts of Parliament, 1999(India).

[11]WTO, https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/trips_e/intel2_e.htm (last visited Mar 8, 2024).

[12] WIPO, https://www.wipo.int/about-ip/en/ (last visited Mar 9, 2024).

[13]WIPO,https://www.wipo.int/patents/en/faq_patents.html#:~:text=How%20long%20does%20patent%20protection,Patents%20are%20territorial%20rights. (last visited Mar 9, 2024).

Disclaimer: The materials provided herein are intended solely for informational purposes. Accessing or using the site or the materials does not establish an attorney-client relationship. The information presented on this site is not to be construed as legal or professional advice, and it should not be relied upon for such purposes or used as a substitute for advice from a licensed attorney in your state. Additionally, the viewpoint presented by the author is of a personal nature.