UNVEILING LEGAL MYSTERIES: OFFERS, INVITATION TO TREAT

This article is written by Shivam Mishra of Vivekananda Institute of Professional Studies, an intern under Legal Vidhiya

ABSTRACT

This article delves into the intricacies of contract law, focusing on the distinctions between offers, and invitations to treat. It dissects the essential elements of an offer, including intention, communication, and clarity, further categorizing them into express, implied, general, specific, and cross-offers. The article also elucidates the concept of invitation to treat, highlighting its role in initiating negotiations and its distinct nature from actual offers. Real-life examples and landmark judicial cases like Balfour v. Balfour and Jones v. Padavatton are cited to reinforce the legal nuances surrounding these concepts. Additionally, the article examines the doctrine of absolute liability, where liability is imposed irrespective of fault, and explores its relevance in specific contexts.

KEYWORDS

Offer, Invitation to Treat, Contract Law, Express offer, Implied offer, General offer, Specific offer, Cross offer, Counter- offer, Balfour V. Balfour, Jones V. Padavatton, Boulton vs. Jones 

INTRODUCTION

The world of contracts hums with unspoken negotiations, where offers and invitations to treat waltz in a delicate dance. This article pulls back the curtain, revealing the key players and their roles in forging binding agreements.

We’ll explore the anatomy of an offer, understanding its essential elements and diverse forms. From bold pronouncements to coy hints, we’ll see how they ignite the negotiation process. Real-life examples will bring these concepts to life, showcasing how everyday encounters can blossom into contracts.

Whether you’re a legal professional, a businessperson, or simply curious about the world of agreements, this article promises a concise and engaging exploration of offers, invitation so, join us as we unveil the captivating dance that binds individuals and shapes the very foundation of contracts.

OFFER

In our everyday life the word offer is so much common that in a day we use this word many time so now coming to what exactly the word mean so An offer is when a seller or buyer makes a conditional offer to buy an asset; if the offer is accepted, it becomes legally binding. Or it can be said as the willingness made by one party to second party to do something it is known as the offer. Or if a person expresses their desire to perform or refrain from performing an action in order to receive agreement from another individual, they are making what is known as a proposal or offer.

Section 2(a) of Indian Contract Act “When one person signifies to another his willingness to do or to abstain from doing anything, with a view to obtaining the assent of that other to such act or abstinence, he is said to make a “proposal” ^[1]it defines offers as A person is said to “make a proposal or offer” when he will indicate to another person that he is willing to do or not do something (abstain) in order to get that person’s approval.

ESSENTIALS

• Firstly it’s a basic necessity which is that there must be two parties in contract one which states their willingness and one against willingness is shared.
• For an offer to take place, communication must be carried out, which involves the establishment of communication between all the relevant parties involved. This communication serves as a crucial component in facilitating the initiation and progression of the aforementioned offer, ensuring that necessary information is exchanged, ideas are shared, and a mutual understanding is reached. Without this vital step of engaging in meaningful dialogue and interaction amongst the concerned individuals or entities, there can be no viable grounds for the occurrence of an offer.
• For an offer to truly take flight and become the foundation of a binding contract, it must be fueled by the powerful engine of intention to create legal relations. This essentially means both parties must agree to be held accountable for their promises under the watchful eye of the law. Without this shared intention, promises remain grounded in the realm of social courtesy or mere pleasantries, lacking the teeth to enforce them through the courts. Imagine a handshake sealed with a formal contract for selling a house, outlining price, terms, and deadlines – this exemplifies a clear and unambiguous intention to create legal relations. Contrast it with a casual invitation to dinner at home – while friendly and hospitable, it lacks the formal language and seriousness that signal legal commitment.
• The offer should clearly define the subject matter being offered, including its precise description, quantity, and any relevant characteristics. Ambiguity in these details can lead to disputes about what was actually offered and accepted.
• Offer could be general or specific
• A defined offer period eliminates ambiguity and ensures both parties understand how long the offer remains valid. This prevents confusion and potential disputes about whether the offer expired before acceptance.
• For an offer to take place having willingness is fundamental
• Promise must be present in order to offer to take place.

CATEGORIES OF OFFER

1. Express Offer– Offers can be conveyed directly, either through spoken words or written documents. These are called Express offers.

Example

• A formal job offer letter stating the position, salary, benefits, and start date.
• A restaurant owner verbally offering a 20% discount on all meals during a specific time period to dine-in customers.
• A website displaying a pop-up ad offering free shipping on orders over a certain amount.

2. Implied Offer – When an explicit offer is absent, the actions or context surrounding the parties’ interaction may give rise to a legally binding offer, even without express words. This implicit manifestation of willingness to enter into an agreement is termed an “implied offer.”

Example

• Boarding a public bus: By displaying the fare price and opening its doors, a bus implies an offer to transport passengers for the stated fare. Entering the bus and paying the fare constitutes acceptance.
• Placing an item on a store shelf with a price tag: This implies an offer to sell the item for that price. Picking up the item and taking it to the checkout signifies acceptance.
• Ordering food at a restaurant: By presenting a menu with prices, a restaurant implies an offer to sell the listed dishes. Placing an order constitutes acceptance.

3. General Offer– A general offer is disseminated to the public as a whole. This universality grants any member of the public the right to initiate acceptance and, upon successful completion of the stipulated terms, acquire the associated rewards or consideration.

Example

• Reward posters: A poster offering a monetary reward for information leading to the arrest of a wanted criminal constitutes a general offer. Any individual fulfilling the conditions (providing the information) becomes the acceptor.
• Public stock offerings: When a company issue shares on the stock market, it makes a general offer to sell those shares to any interested investor who meets the necessary requirements (e.g., having a brokerage account).
• Lottery tickets: By offering a lottery ticket for purchase, the organization implies a general offer to anyone who buys the ticket. Whoever draws the winning numbers becomes the acceptor and claims the prize.

4. Specific Offer – A specific offer is directed towards a readily identifiable individual or group of individuals. The right to accept such an offer is exclusively reserved for the designated addressee(s), precluding acceptance by any unauthorized party.

Example

• Job offer letter: A company extends a specific offer to a shortlisted candidate, outlining the position, salary, benefits, and start date. Only that candidate can accept or reject the offer.
• Personalized sales proposal: A business sends a customized proposal to a potential client, detailing the services, pricing, and timeline tailored to their specific needs. Only the addressed client can accept the offer.
• Contract to purchase a house: A seller makes a specific offer to sell their house to a particular buyer, including the agreed-upon price, closing date, and any special conditions. Only the named buyer can accept the offer.

5. Cross Offer – the legal concept of a cross-offer emerges when, under particular circumstances, two parties, unbeknownst to each other, simultaneously extend identical offers to one another. However, given the absence of prior knowledge of the respective propositions, neither offer can be deemed a valid acceptance, thus precluding the formation of a binding contract.

Example

Scenario 1:

• Alice emails Bob offering to sell her car for $5,000.
• Bob, unaware of Alice’s email, simultaneously emails Alice offering to buy her car for $5,000.

Scenario 2:

• Alice calls Bob saying, “I’ll sell you my bike for $150.”
• Before Alice finishes, Bob interrupts and says, “I’ll buy your bike for $150!”

In both scenarios, neither Alice nor Bob have accepted the other’s offer. This is because they both made their own offers at the same time, without knowledge of the other’s proposal. This situation is called a cross-offer, and it doesn’t create a valid contract.

6. Counter-Offer – A counter-offer represents a response to an initial proposition, whereby the recipient expresses a rejection of the original terms and proposes alternative conditions. This counter-offer effectively negates the initial offer and presents the originator with three options: acceptance, rejection, or the formulation of a revised proposal.

Example

• Job Negotiation: A company offers a candidate a $50,000 salary. The candidate counters with a $55,000 request, proposing a higher compensation.
• Contract Renegotiation: A supplier provides a quote for $10,000 for a project. The client counters with $8,500, seeking a lower price.
• Real Estate Purchase: A buyer offers $350,000 for a house. The seller counters with $375,000, aiming for a higher selling price.

VALID AND COMMON CONDITIONS FOR THE REVOCATION OF AN OFFER.

• “An offer expires after a set or reasonable amount of time if not accepted.”
• “Failure to adhere to the specific acceptance conditions cancels the offer.”
• “Rejection terminates the validity of an offer.”
•  “The validity of an offer is suspended if the proposer or their authorized representative becomes deceased or incapacitated before acceptance.”
• “An offer is gone if it’s taken back before someone accepts it.”
• “An offer ends if it becomes illegal or the thing being offered is no longer available.”

RELEVANT JUDICIAL CASES

Balfour v. Balfour^[2]

Setting: Ceylon (now Sri Lanka), 1915. Mr. Balfour, a government engineer, and his wife are living apart temporarily due to her illness. He promises her monthly financial support until their reunion.       

Conflict: Despite the promise, Mr. Balfour stops the payments. Mrs. Balfour sues him for the owed money.

Issue: Did Mr. Balfour’s promise constitute a legally binding contract?

Court’s Decision: No. Although Mr. Balfour made a promise, the court found no intention to create legal relations. This element is crucial for a contract to be enforceable. The court considered factors like the context of their relationship and the informality of the arrangement.

Impact: This case sets a precedent for contractual agreements, emphasizing the importance of clear and demonstrable intention to create legal obligations

Jones v. Padavatton^[3]

Setting: England, 1964. Mrs. Jones agrees to pay her daughter, Mrs. Padavatton, $200 per month if she returns from the US to study law in England. Later, Mrs. Jones alters the deal by offering part of her house for Padavatton to live in and rent out, covering her expenses. After a 1967 argument, Jones sues for possession of the house, claiming the agreement lacked legal intention.

Issue: Did the mother-daughter agreement to support the daughter’s studies in exchange for rent-generating accommodation create a legally binding contract?

Court’s Decision: No. Though an agreement existed, the court found no intention to create legal relations. The court considered the informal nature of the arrangement, including its modification and the close family relationship, suggesting it was more a familial understanding than a formal contract.

Impact: This case reinforces the importance of intention to create legal relations in contract formation. Although agreements exist, not all are intended to be enforceable through the law.

Boulton vs. Jones ^[4]

Facts:

• Jones, a construction materials company owner, was a regular customer of Brocklehurst.
• Jones placed a written order for supplies with Brocklehurst.
• Brocklehurst was acquired by Boulton, but Jones was unaware of the change.
• Boulton fulfilled the order without informing Jones of the acquisition.
• Jones used the materials, believing they came from Brocklehurst.

Issues:

1. Liability for Payment: Was Jones liable to pay Boulton for the supplies?
2. Duty to Inform: Did Boulton have a duty to inform Jones about the acquisition?

Judgment:

• The court ruled that Jones was not liable to pay Boulton.
• The court found that there was no valid contract between Jones and Boulton, as Jones intended to contract with Brocklehurst.
• The court also found that Boulton had no duty to inform Jones about the acquisition.

INVITATION TO TREAT

Within the intricate world of contract law, lies a fascinating concept known as the invitation to treat, also called invitation to bargain in the U.S. This Latin phrase, invitatio ad offerendum, translates to “inviting an offer”, perfectly capturing the essence of what it truly represents.

Think of it as a beacon in the marketplace, beckoning potential buyers with a glimpse of what’s available. It’s not a legally binding offer itself, but rather a spark that ignites the negotiation process. Imagine a shop window displaying a price tag on a dress – that’s an invitation to treat, not a guarantee of selling it for that exact price.

But its role is far from insignificant. It’s the crucial first step that bridges the gap between a mere product and a potential agreement. It sets the stage for a dance of proposals and counterproposals, ultimately leading to a binding contract (or perhaps, a friendly “no thank you”).

Here’s an enlarged perspective on how this dynamic unfolds:

1. The Invitation: A seller displays a price tag, advertises a service, or presents an auction bid. This is the invitation to treat, extending the possibility of a deal.
2. The Offer: The potential buyer responds with a specific proposal, like stating their desired price or agreeing to the advertised terms. This is the actual offer, building upon the foundation laid by the invitation.
3. The Dance Begins: The seller can either accept the offer (forming a binding contract), reject it, or propose a counteroffer. This back-and-forth exchange is the negotiation dance, fueled by the initial invitation.
4. Reaching Consensus: When both parties agree on terms, a binding contract is born. If no agreement is reached, the negotiation ends and the invitation to treat loses its purpose.

Understanding the invitation to treat is like having a backstage pass to the world of contracts. It reveals the subtle choreography of offers and negotiations, and how a simple “invitation” can pave the way for legally binding agreements.

EVERYDAY EXAMPLES

In the world of contracts, there’s a fascinating concept called an invitation to treat. It’s like a siren song of possibilities, beckoning potential buyers without quite guaranteeing a deal. Imagine it as a shop window displaying a price tag – inviting you to step in and make an offer, not promising to sell at that exact price.

So, here are some everyday examples of this intriguing concept

1. Advertisements: Catchy commercials, enticing billboards, and online banners – these are all invitations to treat. They present goods and services, hoping to spark your interest and prompt an offer. But they lack the crucial details to be actual offers, like specific terms and conditions. This allows sellers to adjust prices if needed, without being legally bound to honor mistakenly advertised costs.

2. Auction Halls: The thrill of bidding at an auction? That’s the dance of invitations to treat in action! Each time the auctioneer raises the gavel, they’re not guaranteeing the item to the highest bidder. Instead, they’re inviting everyone to make offers, creating a dynamic negotiation process where the final call determines the winner.

3. Shop Shelves and Catalogs: From neatly arranged groceries to online catalogs brimming with options, these are all invitations to treat. They showcase products, sparking your desire and inviting you to make an offer to purchase. It’s only when you approach the cashier or click “buy” that the negotiation truly begins, with the seller accepting or rejecting your offer.

4. Tender Process: Imagine receiving a request for proposals for a big project. That’s an invitation to treat! The organization is seeking potential partners, inviting them to submit proposals (offers) outlining their solutions and terms. It’s up to the organization to accept or reject these offers, ultimately choosing the one that best suits their needs.

DISTINCTION BETWEEN THE OFFER AND INVITATION TO TREAT

BASIS OF DIFFRENCE	OFFER	INVITATION TO TREAT
Definition	A statement of terms upon which the offeror is willing to be bound if accepted	A display or communication inviting others to make offers
Intention	To create a binding contract if accepted	To spark negotiation or receive offers
Specificity	Includes specific terms and conditions (e.g., price, quantity, delivery)	May lack details or leave terms open for negotiation
Example	“will sell you my car for $10,000.”	A car displayed in a showroom with a price tag
Acceptance & Binding Contract	Acceptance (e.g., saying “I accept”) forms a binding contract	Responding (e.g., making an offer) becomes the actual offer, not an acceptance

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, the legal tapestry of contract formation is intricately woven with the threads of offers and invitations to treat. This article has endeavored to elucidate these fundamental concepts, dissecting their nuanced roles and contrasting their distinct characteristics.

By delving into the anatomy of an offer, we have examined the essential elements that breathe life into these propositions, from their inherent intention to their diverse forms. We have witnessed how express pronouncements and implied gestures can ignite the negotiation process, culminating in mutually agreeable contracts. Real-world examples have served as illuminating vignettes, demonstrating how seemingly mundane encounters can metamorphose into legally binding arrangements.

Turning our gaze to the captivating realm of invitations to treat, we have unveiled their captivating nature as alluring beacons of possibility, beckoning potential parties into the negotiation arena without preordaining a conclusive agreement. Yet, their role is far from

REFERENCES

TIMES OF INDIA

IPLEADERS

HINDUSTAN TIMES

BYJUS

MANUPATRA

LEGAL SERVICES

---

^[1] Sec 2 of Indian Contract Act

^[2] Balfour v Balfour [1919] 2 KB 571

^[3] [1968] EWCA Civ 4, [1969] 1 WLR 328; All ER 616

^[4] In Boulton vs. Jones 1857

Disclaimer: The materials provided herein are intended solely for informational purposes. Accessing or using the site or the materials does not establish an attorney-client relationship. The information presented on this site is not to be construed as legal or professional advice, and it should not be relied upon for such purposes or used as a substitute for advice from a licensed attorney in your state. Additionally, the viewpoint presented by the author is of a personal nature.