THE ROLE OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY IN INCENTIVIZING INVESTMENT IN CLEAN ENERGY

ABSTRACT

The role of intellectual property (I.P.) rights in incentivizing investment in clean energy is crucial for fostering innovation and protecting the environment. This paper examines the significance of patents and trade secrets in promoting clean energy technologies, highlighting their role in stimulating research and development, attracting investment, and facilitating technology transfer. It also discusses the concept of open innovation in green technology. It explores initiatives like WIPO GREEN and the Eco-Patents Commons, which aim to accelerate the dissemination of green technologies. Through case studies and analysis, this paper demonstrates the importance of robust I.P. protection in driving the transition to a sustainable, low-carbon economy.

Keywords

Intellectual property, Clean Energy, Innovation, Technology, Sustainable

INTRODUCTION

For more than two weeks, thousands of individuals in Ladakh have been protesting in demand of constitutional provisions from the Indian government for depleting their ecology due to climate change. The Pledge, during C.O.P. 28, which mandates signatories to cooperate in tripling the world’s installed renewable energy generation capacity to at least 11,000 GW by 2030,[1] is of particular interest to them. It also calls for doubling the global average annual rate of energy efficiency improvements from around 2% to over 4% every year until 2030[2]. Renewable energy sources are becoming increasingly critical to the energy mix. The case for investing in renewable energy technologies is becoming more compelling for businesses. Intellectual property is necessary for businesses to safeguard their investments in research and development. It also allows them to maximize business returns and distinguish themselves in an intensely competitive market. Patents are crucial in protecting technology rights, particularly in the renewable energy sector. The majority of renewable energy investment is still in solar and wind energy. According to a 2020 study by the World Intellectual Property Office, over half of all renewables-related patent applications were in the solar technology category, with roughly 25% of them relating to wind.[3] In addition to patents, renewable energy companies also rely on and safeguard trade secrets and confidential hardware and manufacturing information. This could include confidential design documents, data interpretation, and analysis results, or the algorithms and software developed to analyze the data. IPR is an important determinant of renewable energy production and depletion of non-renewable resources taking place at an alarming rate it is necessary to adopt a change towards green technologies and stronger protection of IP right in this field.[4]

By establishing a strong framework of intellectual property rights, we can cultivate an environment that stimulates innovation and creativity, motivating creators to monetize their work through licensing and other standard channels. This approach not only fuels research and development, growth, employment, and ongoing innovation and expansion, but it also benefits the environment. Over time, safeguarding intellectual property rights can also result in reduced costs for products and processes, which is essential for optimizing the potential of clean energy and expanding its influence to other regions, including developing economies. Additionally, protecting IP rights guarantees that third parties cannot utilize the holder’s invention without permission, enabling the holder to exploit their invention with complete authorization securely.

In 2013, the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) introduced an innovative initiative named WIPO GREEN[5]. This online platform has been meticulously designed to combat the pressing issue of global climate change. It achieves this by fostering the development and widespread distribution of green technologies, which is crucial in mitigating environmental challenges. WIPO GREEN serves as a vital connector, facilitating interactions between the owners and developers of these technologies and stakeholders interested in their commercialization, licensing, and distribution on a global scale. This initiative leverages technological solutions to address environmental problems across various sectors and regions.

By 2019, WIPO proudly announced that WIPO GREEN had reached a remarkable milestone of 3,000 entries.[6] This achievement underscores the platform’s effectiveness in attracting a wide array of green technologies and innovations. The core philosophy behind WIPO GREEN is to make intellectual property (IP) work in favor of environmental sustainability. By providing a secure framework for IP rights, the platform enhances the appeal of green technologies to potential investors and partners. This security acts as a strong incentive for developers, encouraging them to engage in collaborations and ventures that have the potential to scale their technologies. Such partnerships not only accelerate the dissemination of green technologies but also ensure that the developers’ investments and innovations are protected.

The platform’s success is a testament to the growing recognition of the critical role that intellectual property rights play in facilitating the transition to a green economy. By marrying the objectives of environmental sustainability with IP management, WIPO GREEN is effectively contributing to the global effort to combat climate change. It opens up new avenues for sustainable development by making green technologies more accessible and appealing to a broad audience, including entrepreneurs, researchers, and policymakers. Through its comprehensive database and networking opportunities, WIPO GREEN is laying the groundwork for a future where green technologies are at the forefront of addressing the world’s most pressing environmental challenges.

PATENTS AS A WAY TO ENCOURAGE INNOVATION IN CLEAN ENERGY

Patents, representing a critical facet of intellectual property rights, confer temporary exclusive privileges to inventors or their assignees. This exclusivity not only allows entities to recoup a fraction of the value added through their inventive activities and the associated developmental and market introduction investments but also serves as an instrumental beacon of value, particularly to investors and prospective collaborators. Essentially, patents perform a dual role: first, as a protective measure safeguarding the commercial interests of innovators, and second, as a signaling mechanism that communicates the potential value and viability of the patented technology to relevant stakeholders.[7]

Moreover, patents are pivotal in fostering an ecosystem conducive to technological collaborations and partnerships. These collaborative endeavors are instrumental in facilitating technological diffusion and fostering innovation, which are vital for addressing contemporary challenges such as climate change. For example, synergies between government entities and startup companies, particularly in the realm of green technology, have been shown to significantly accelerate patenting activity, thus promoting the development and adoption of sustainable solutions. The University of Cambridge, in a 2019 study, highlighted that the patenting activity of new green technology startups in the United States surged by over 73% on average following collaborative engagements with government agencies, underscoring the potential of such partnerships in driving technological innovation and environmental sustainability.

In addition to acting as catalysts for investment, patents play a crucial role in the broader ecosystem of knowledge and technology transfer. Each granted patent contributes to a growing repository of published patents, which collectively forms an expansive library of cutting-edge and robust information on the latest technological advancements. This repository not only serves as a testament to human ingenuity and progress but also as a valuable resource for researchers, entrepreneurs, and policymakers[8]. It enables the regionalization of technology by facilitating access to and adaptation of innovative solutions across different contexts and geographies, thereby enhancing the global diffusion of technology.

In summary, patents are indispensable in the contemporary landscape of innovation and technological development. They not only provide a mechanism for protecting and monetizing intellectual property but also play a significant role in signaling value, fostering collaborations, and facilitating the dissemination of knowledge and technology. As such, the strategic utilization of patents is integral to nurturing an environment that supports innovation, economic growth, and the addressing of pressing global challenges.

TRADE SECRETS IN PROMOTING CLEAN ENERGY

Trade secrets encompass confidential information that holds commercial value, which may not be amenable to the rigors of patenting or, in strategic instances, is deliberately safeguarded through mechanisms of trade secret protection as an alternative to obtaining patents. This category of intellectual property plays an indispensable role in the promotion and safeguarding of the channels through which the exchange of proprietary knowledge occurs. By creating a secure environment for the diffusion of such knowledge, trade secrets facilitate the continued innovation and competitive advantage of businesses and industries.[9]

A salient example of the critical nature of trade secrets and the governmental measures to protect them can be observed in the actions undertaken by the United States Government against the misappropriation of proprietary trade secrets by Chinese entities from companies within the renewable energy sector, such as Solar World and the American Superconductor Corporation. These instances underscore the broader implications and necessity of robust trade secret protection to safeguard national and economic interests.

Furthermore, trade secrets serve to protect the tacit knowledge that underpins the processes of embedding, enhancing, and adapting technologies that may already be patented. This aspect is particularly pertinent in the sphere of green technologies, where the adaptation of such technologies to local conditions is imperative for both developed and developing countries.

The protection of trade secrets, in this context, emerges as a crucial factor that enables the customization and implementation of green technologies to meet specific environmental and economic needs.

However, the absence of effective protection mechanisms for trade secrets can compel companies to allocate substantial resources towards the physical security of their confidential information, diverting funds and focus away from vital research and development efforts. This scenario not only stifles innovation but also undermines the potential for technological advancement and economic growth. Empirical evidence supports the existence of a positive correlation between the intensity of research and development investment and the strength of trade secrets protection. This correlation highlights the importance of trade secrets as a critical component of a comprehensive intellectual property strategy, underscoring their role in fostering an environment conducive to innovation, competitive advantage, and sustainable development.

In conclusion, the protection of trade secrets is paramount in the modern economic landscape, serving as a key pillar supporting the exchange of knowledge, the advancement of technology, and the promotion of sustainable practices. As such, policymakers and industry leaders must continue to recognize and reinforce the mechanisms of trade secret protection to ensure continued prosperity and innovation within the global economy.

OPEN INNOVATION AND I.P.R. IN GREEN TECHNOLOGY

Contrasting with the traditional model of Intellectual Property Rights are Open Access initiatives, which advocate for making information and creative works freely accessible to everyone. This approach stands in direct opposition to the exclusivity typically associated with I.P.R.[10]

Green technology frequently aligns with the paradigm of “open innovation,” wherein enterprises engage with external entities and collaborators to augment innovation. Given the intricate nature of environmental technologies and the global extent of climate change alongside environmental concerns, the facilitation of open innovation, buttressed by robust protection of intellectual property rights, becomes imperative to foster the invention and diffusion of these technologies.

Collaborative frameworks that encompass both public and private sectors, in conjunction with research institutions and organizations, have demonstrated efficacy in catalysing the development and dissemination of green technologies. An exemplar of such collaborative endeavors is WIPO Green. Additionally, the Eco-Patents Commons initiative, spearheaded by IBM, Nokia, Sony, and Pitney Bowes in 2008, stands as a noteworthy venture.[11] This non-profit initiative proffers royalty-free access to an array of patents that encapsulate environmentally benign inventions with the objective of facilitating the proliferation of critical green technologies, encompassing but not limited to energy conservation, pollution mitigation, recycling, and water conservation.

STEPS FURTHER TO PROMOTE CLEAN ENERGY VIA IPR

To secure additional financing for a green technology enterprise aimed at advancing a prototype towards market readiness, it is imperative to explore multifaceted strategies. One such strategy involves leveraging the firm’s core intellectual property (IP) as collateral to raise growth finance. This approach is substantiated by our prior experience in the valuation of IP assets within a sustainable urban farming enterprise, showcasing our proficiency in discerning the intrinsic value of green technologies.

Moreover, the facilitation of a collaborative green initiative necessitates the strategic ring-fencing and valuation of IP committed to the venture, ensuring that the innovative potential is fully realized and protected. The imperative to safeguard innovative IP from obsolescence or loss, especially in scenarios of insolvency, calls for a proactive stance. The divestiture of IP assets under financial distress must be pursued to enable the commercialization of technology, thereby preserving the investments made towards green innovation to date.

Illustrative of this approach is our engagement with Catalyst Systems, wherein the valuation and subsequent sale of IP assets pertaining to innovative water decontamination technology were executed. Similarly, the disposition of assets from a wind turbine servicing firm further exemplifies the strategic reallocation of resources to foster the commercial viability of green technologies.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, intellectual property rights are essential for incentivizing investment in clean energy and driving innovation in the green technology sector. Patents and trade secrets play a crucial role in protecting innovative technologies, attracting investment, and fostering collaboration. Initiatives like WIPO GREEN and the Eco-Patents Commons further promote the dissemination of green technologies by providing a platform for sharing and accessing IP. To promote clean energy effectively, policymakers and industry stakeholders must continue to recognize the importance of IP rights and work towards creating a conducive environment for innovation and collaboration in the green technology sector.

REFERENCES

C.O.P. 28: Charting the Roadmap for Climate Action, DRISHTI IAS (Dec. 15, 2023), .https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-editorials/cop-28-charting-the-roadmap-for-climate-action.
Jon Moorhouse, The Role of Intellectual Property in the Renewable Energy Sector, KEYNOTES (Sept. 7, 2021),https://www.keystonelaw.com/keynotes/the-role-of-intellectual-property-in-the-renewable-energy-sector.
Akanksha Mathur, Significance of IPR in safeguarding business goals of the renewable energy industry, ECON. TIMES ENERGY (insert publication date if available),https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/renewable/significance-of-ipr-in-safeguarding-business-goals-of-the-renewable-energy-industry/99737973.
WIPO, https://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/convention/summary_wipo_convention.html#:~:text=The%20WIPO%20Convention%2C%20the%20constituent,and%20was%20amended%20in%201979. (last visited Mar 21, 2024).
The Role of IP Rights in Green Technologies Innovation,” METIS PARTNERS,.https://metispartners.com/thought-leadership/the-role-of-ip-rights-in-green-technologies-innovation/.
Deepika Kapoor, Open Access Movements and Intellectual Property Considerations, LEGAL VIDHIYA (Mar. 29, 2024), https://legalvidhiya.com/open-access-movements-and-intellectual-property-considerations/.

[1]C.O.P. 28: Charting the Roadmap for Climate Action, DRISHTI IAS (Dec. 15, 2023), .https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-editorials/cop-28-charting-the-roadmap-for-climate-action.

[2] C.O.P. 28: Charting the Roadmap for Climate Action, DRISHTI IAS (Dec. 15, 2023), .https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-editorials/cop-28-charting-the-roadmap-for-climate-action.

[3] Jon Moorhouse, The Role of Intellectual Property in the Renewable Energy Sector, KEYNOTES (Sept. 7, 2021),https://www.keystonelaw.com/keynotes/the-role-of-intellectual-property-in-the-renewable-energy-sector.

[4] Akanksha Mathur, Significance of IPR in safeguarding business goals of the renewable energy industry, ECON. TIMES ENERGY (insert publication date if available),https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/renewable/significance-of-ipr-in-safeguarding-business-goals-of-the-renewable-energy-industry/99737973.

[5] WIPO, https://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/convention/summary_wipo_convention.html#:~:text=The%20WIPO%20Convention%2C%20the%20constituent,and%20was%20amended%20in%201979. (last visited Mar 21, 2024).

[6] WIPO, https://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/convention/summary_wipo_convention.html#:~:text=The%20WIPO%20Convention%2C%20the%20constituent,and%20was%20amended%20in%201979. (last visited Mar 21, 2024).

[7] The Role of IP Rights in Green Technologies Innovation,” METIS PARTNERS,.https://metispartners.com/thought-leadership/the-role-of-ip-rights-in-green-technologies-innovation/.

[8] The Role of IP Rights in Green Technologies Innovation,” METIS PARTNERS,.https://metispartners.com/thought-leadership/the-role-of-ip-rights-in-green-technologies-innovation/.

[9] The Role of IP Rights in Green Technologies Innovation,” METIS PARTNERS,.https://metispartners.com/thought-leadership/the-role-of-ip-rights-in-green-technologies-innovation/.

[10] Deepika Kapoor, Open Access Movements and Intellectual Property Considerations, LEGAL VIDHIYA (Mar. 29, 2024), https://legalvidhiya.com/open-access-movements-and-intellectual-property-considerations/.

[11] The Role of IP Rights in Green Technologies Innovation,” METIS PARTNERS,.https://metispartners.com/thought-leadership/the-role-of-ip-rights-in-green-technologies-innovation/.

Disclaimer: The materials provided herein are intended solely for informational purposes. Accessing or using the site or the materials does not establish an attorney-client relationship. The information presented on this site is not to be construed as legal or professional advice, and it should not be relied upon for such purposes or used as a substitute for advice from a licensed attorney in your state. Additionally, the viewpoint presented by the author is of a personal nature.