This Article is written by Akshara Verma of Lloyd School of Law, Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh, an intern under Legal Vidhiya
Abstract
This article scrutinizes the laws governing civil marriages in India, as discussed in the 212th Law Commission Report. It assesses proposed amendments intended to resolve disputes, specifically focusing on marriage age, prohibition of child marriage, interfaith marriages, divorce, alimony, and property rights. The article underlines the need to reassess and update these laws in response to social changes, constitutional values and principles of gender justice. Further, it investigates the proposal of introducing a uniform civil code to manage these legal conflicts. It highlights the controversy and complexities that surround this proposition. Finally, it underlines the requirement of significant research, wider consultations, and cautious drafting in shaping these laws and implementing reformations.
Keywords
Special Marriage Act, Hindu Marriage Act, Foreign Marriage Act, inter-caste, interfaith, non-religious, same-sex marriage, Indian Christian Marriage Act, 212th report of Law Commission of India.
Introduction
Marriage, one of the oldest social institutions, holds great cultural significance and a plethora of legal implications, particularly in a diverse country like India where civil marriage laws vary across religions and cultures. These different laws often lead to conflicts and challenges due to their differing requirements and outcomes, requiring effective resolution to ensure harmony and equity in society. This article will analyze the Law Commission of India’s 212th report on the Proposal to Resolve Certain Conflicts in Civil Marriage Laws in India, aiming to harmonize the diversity of marriage laws. The Commission addresses the main issues of different age requirements, marriage registration processes, divorce provisions, and consequences of void or voidable marriages under various marriage acts. They propose an inclusive marriage law that can cut across religions and cultural boundaries, in line with India’s secular credentials. This examination seeks to illuminate the main concerns and suggestions brought forward by this influential report, thus opening a wider discussion on the modernization and inclusivity of India’s marriage laws.
“Keeping this in mind, the Law Commission has suggested certain amendments in both the Special Marriage Act, 1954 and the Foreign Marriage Act, 1969 so that their provisions become uniformly available to a larger number of marriages of all Indian communities. If accepted and implemented, the recommendations will go a long way in popularizing civil marriages.”
Understanding the Basic Concept of Civil Marriages in India
In India, civil marriages provide an alternative to religious ceremonies and are governed by the Special Marriage Act of 1954. This Act allows marriages between couples irrespective of their religion, caste, or creed. This law is especially beneficial for couples from different faiths or for those who wish to marry without the involvement of religious customs.
To have a civil marriage in India, a couple must meet certain conditions. They must be at least 21 years old (for males) or 18 years old (for females), they must give their consent willingly, and neither party can have a living spouse at the time of marriage. Also, the couple should not fall within the prohibited degree of relationship unless permitted by their custom or usage.
The procedure for a civil marriage includes a 30-day notice period in which the couple’s intention to marry is announced to allow any objections. If no objection arises, the marriage is conducted before a marriage officer and is signed by the couple, along with three witnesses.
Overall, civil marriages in India provide a progressive way for couples to marry in a manner that goes beyond traditional religious boundaries, fostering inclusivity and mutual respect for diversity. This form of marriage highlights the core principle of the Indian constitution – equality before law irrespective of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth.
History of Civil Marriage Laws in India
Civil marriages in India are legally sanctioned through the Special Marriage Act, 1954. This act was implemented to facilitate the solemnization of civil marriages in India between individuals irrespective of their religion or faith. It replaced the former British India-era law, The Foreign Marriage Act, 1892.
Over time, conflicts and issues arose within the legal purview of civil marriages, pertaining to varying religious customs, norms and rights of individuals in India. These issues called for an in-depth legal analysis and resulted in Law Commission of India releasing the 212th report in 2008, titled ‘Laws of Civil Marriages in India – A Proposal to Resolve Certain Conflicts’. The report mainly addresses three issues related to the law governing civil marriages – the Notice of Intended Marriage, the Solemnization Place, and the Objection to Marriage.
Firstly, the current requirement for a Notice of Intended Marriage is perceived as a breach of the right to privacy. The 212th report suggests amendments to maintain privacy yet provide proof of intention. Secondly, it was proposed to modify the place of solemnization, providing flexibility to parties. Lastly, the ‘objection to marriage’ provision was scrutinized and amendments were recommended to safeguard against false and malicious objections.
The historical journey of civil marriage laws in India is characterized by an ongoing need to balance between varying cultural values, social norms and the legal framework. Over the years, legal reports and proposals like Report No. 212 have played a pivotal role in suggesting modifications to enhance inclusivity and harmony in civil marriage laws in India.
Disparities in Civil Marriage Laws – Conflicts and Solutions
India, with its vast diversity in terms of culture and religion, is home to various forms of personal laws governing different aspects of a person’s life. Civil marriage laws are among these, marked by vast disparities, inconsistencies, and sometimes conflicting religious personal laws. A profound reflection of this is the 212th Law Commission Report which discusses these disparities and offers proposals for a fair, universal law for civil marriages in India.
The Law Commission report makes it clear that marriage laws in India are compartmentalized according to religions and therefore fail to comply with universal human rights. The rights of those who want to marry outside their religion or those not willing to conform to religious dictates remain ignored, posing issues of social justice. The absence of an option for a civil marriage makes it difficult for interfaith couples to exercise their right to marry without renouncing their religious identity.
The Report proposed a Special Marriage Act reform, giving everyone an opportunity to choose a non-religious, secular law governing their marriage and divorce, thus ensuring social justice and freedom to interfaith and inter-caste couples. It underlines the need for India, as a secular state, to allow its citizens the option of civil marriages irrespective of religion or caste.
To tackle religious backlash and conflict, the report advocates that the civil law should not be mandatory, instead giving the option of both personal religious laws and the Special Marriage Act. It suggests sensitizing society about this reform through media, and suggests inclusion in the education system.
Overall, the report seeks to alleviate disparities and promote harmony in Indian society through this proposal, hence keeping India on a path towards modernity while retaining its diversity.
Interfaith and Inter-caste Marriages: The Legal Challenges
The Laws of Civil Marriages in India, as highlighted in the Law Commission of India Report No. 212, grapples with various complexities around interfaith and inter-caste marriages. The inherent sociocultural, religious, and legal barriers often create problems for couples involved in such unions. At the core of these challenges are certain restrictions put forth by different personal laws which tend to discourage or restrict marriages between people of different faiths or castes. For instance, the Hindu Marriage Act recognizes marriages only between Hindus, failing to address marriages between a Hindu and a non-Hindu, unless the latter converts.
In this context, the Special Marriage Act of 1954 can be seen as a relatively liberal legislation that allows interfaith and inter-caste marriages. However, its procedural complexities and the demand of public notice period makes couples vulnerable to familial and societal pressure. This ultimately acts as a deterrent for those considering such unions. To mitigate these issues, the report proposes reform measures. Firstly, it suggests a single, uniform, secular law to govern all marriages in the country, irrespective of the religion or caste of the individuals. This can help in overcoming religious constraints imposed by personal laws and can strengthen secularism.
Secondly, the report recommends amendments in the procedural aspects of the Special Marriage Act. These amendments may include simplifying the procedures, removing the public notice requirement, ensuring confidentiality and speeding up the process to eliminate societal pressures. These proposed reforms seek to facilitate interfaith and inter-caste marriages, protecting individual freedom and the constitutional rights to equality and non-discrimination. However, implementation of these reforms will require addressing socio-religious sensibilities delicately. These laws are likely to incite resistance from religious communities fearing infringement of their personal laws, necessitating thoughtful, comprehensive legal strategies.
Legal Reform Suggestions: A Closer Look at the Proposal
The Law Commission of India’s Report No. 212 provides valuable insights into the topic of laws pertaining to civil marriages in India. With increasing awareness of human rights and an expansion in personal freedom, the state has been faced with multiple legal dilemmas involving marriage law.
It’s worth mentioning that in India, marriage law falls under personal laws. In essence, every religious community has its own marriage laws, such as Hindu Marriage Act for Hindus, Indian Christian Marriage Act for Christians, and the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act for Muslims, to name a few. While the specific details vary greatly, there exists the Special Marriage Act of 1954 for couples opting for a non-religious, civil marriage. The complication arises due to the concurrent operation of personal and civil laws, often leading to legal loopholes and gray areas.
Reform proposal suggested by the Law Commission in Report no. 212 makes some critical observations about this matter. This article closely looks at the suggested reform proposal and the contexts within which they are made.
1. Introduction of a Compulsory Registration Clause: As of now, marriage registration isn’t mandatory under any law. This lack of compulsory registration causes various complications, particularly for women, especially when claiming alimony, child custody, or property. This clause makes registration obligatory, thus creating a reliable proof of marriage.
2. Need for Uniform Age for Marriage: Different marriage laws propose different minimum age criteria for marriage, resulting in inconsistency. It is recommended to establish a uniform age for marriage, across all religions, which can contribute to reducing child marriage.
3. Monogamy, Maintenance, and Alimony: The clause proposes a universal enforcement of monogamy regardless of religious practice. The rules around maintenance and alimony must be clarified and implemented consistently across all religions.
4. Grounds for Divorce: These need to be standardized across all religious communities, with particular focus on amending subjective clauses such as cruelty, desertion, and adultery.
5. Inclusion of LGBTQ+ Community: Considering the decriminalization of Section 377 by the Supreme Court of India, it’s high time to extend marriage laws to accommodate marriages from the LGBTQ+ community.
These suggestions, if effectively executed, would significantly contribute towards creating a more inclusive, fair, and gender-neutral marriage law in India. In conclusion, a serious discourse, policy amendment, and their timely enforcement are required to implement the proposals of the Law Commission in their true spirit and essence. This may go a long way in the path of social progress, the upliftment of human rights and promoting the principle of gender equality
The Need for Unification of Marriage Laws in India :
India, as a country with great cultural and religious diversity, currently follows a personal laws system for marriage where each religion has a set of distinct marriage laws. The diversity and complexity of these laws sometimes leads to conflicts, discriminatory practices and challenges related to human rights and gender equality. It becomes increasingly evident, thus, the need for unification of marriage laws in the country.
One possible solution could be a Uniform Civil Code (UCC), proposed by the Law Commission of India, which has sparked debates for its implications on cultural and religious autonomy. Yet, one cannot overlook the essential premise of a UCC – it aims at a simplified legal structure, a more equitable justice delivery system, and, fundamentally, greater gender justice.
Such a unified law for marriage could ensure gender equality by abolishing the patriarchal biases present in many existing laws. For instance, it could remove the requirement for a bride’s father’s presence in a Hindu marriage or could deal with unequal grounds for divorce between men and women in certain communities.
Another critical area is the need for recognizing inter-faith marriages. A unified civil marriage law could provide an effective legal recognition to these marriages, protecting the rights of those who choose to marry outside their religion.
To effectively introduce and implement such unified law, considerable efforts must be dedicated towards educating citizens about its benefits, reassuring them that it does not pose any threat to their cultural or religious identity.
Unification of marriage laws in India is not about homogenizing diverse cultural practices. It’s about establishing an egalitarian social order that respects every individual’s right to justice, regardless of gender, religion, or community. The laws of civil marriages could indeed benefit from a coherent and fair legal structure for all Indian citizens.
The Prohibited Degrees in Marriage :
The concept of prohibited degrees in marriage relates to cultural, religious, and legal restrictions placed on whom an individual may marry based on familial relationships. These prohibited degrees are often based on blood relationships (consanguinity), but they may also extend to relations by marriage (affinity).
In detail, the Prohibited Degrees in Marriage are:
1. Parent-Child Relationships: This prohibition typically extends to biological parents and their children, adoptive parents and their adoptive children, and stepparents and their stepchildren. In most jurisdictions, it is considered illegal and socially unacceptable for parents to marry their children or stepchildren.
2. Sibling Relationships: In many cultures, it is prohibited for full siblings to marry each other. The prohibition can extend to half-siblings and, in some cultures, to step-siblings as well.
3. Grandparent-Grandchild Relationships: This restriction extends across most societies and legal systems, which forbid marriage between grandparents and their grandchildren.
4. Uncle-niece, Aunt-Nephew Relationships: These marriages are often considered incestuous and are thus prohibited in many societies, although this varies considerably between different cultures and religions.
5. First Cousin Relationships: In some jurisdictions and cultures, marriages between first cousins are prohibited, but this is not a universally applied prohibition. In some societies, first-cousin marriages are common and even encouraged.
6. Relationships by Affinity: These prohibitions can extend to relationships created through marriage, such as between a person and their in-laws. For example, a man may be prohibited from marrying his deceased wife’s sister or his divorced wife’s mother in certain cultures or legal systems.
In many cases, these prohibitions are defined by both legal and religious systems, which may be codified in civil law or religious texts. Violation of these prohibitions can lead to criminal charges, such as those related to incest, in many legal jurisdictions. It is worth noting, however, that the specific details and definitions of prohibited degrees in marriage can vary significantly between different societies, cultures, religions, and legal systems.
As a result, individuals seeking to enter into a marriage should carefully consider their own cultural, religious, and legal context. It may be beneficial to consult with legal experts or religious leaders for guidance regarding these potential prohibitions.
The Applicable Law of Succession :
The Indian Succession Act of 1925 lays down a comprehensive and uniform system of the law of intestate succession or testamentary succession, applicable to all citizens of India, except the state of Jammu and Kashmir and the exceptions mentioned below:
1. Different religious communities in India follow different inheritance laws, which are applicable to those communities.
2. For Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs, the laws of succession are codified in the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, which applies to any person who is a Hindu, Buddhist, Jain, or Sikh by religion.
3. For Parsis, the Parsi Intestate Succession Act (1865) is applicable. It applies to every Parsi dying, after the commencement of the Indian Succession Act 1925.
4. Muslims in India do not have a codified law of succession but follow the principles of the Sharia law.
5. The Christian Law of Succession is governed by the Indian Succession Act, 1925.
Hindu Succession Act 1956:
This Act regulates the succession to the property of a Hindu male or female who dies intestate, i.e., without a will. It covers aspects such as survivorship, succession, distribution, rights of a child in the womb, escheat, etc. The law gives preference to Class I heirs, such as the spouse, children, and mother of the deceased, who are entitled to obtain the property simultaneously.
Muslim Law of Succession:
In Islamic law, inheritance plays a crucial role. The law stipulates the portion of the property that each heir should receive after the payment of debts and funeral expenses. However, a Muslim person can bequeath only one-third of his/her property through a will, and the rest should be distributed among legal heirs as per the rules laid down by Sharia law.
Parsi and Christian Law of Succession:
In both Parsi and Christian law, intestate succession is governed by the Indian Succession Act of 1925. However, Parsis have a separate set of rules as to the distribution of property, laid down in the Schedule appended to the Indian Succession Act, 1925. For Christians, the law differentiates between movable and immovable property.
While these laws provide a detailed framework for succession in different religious communities, issues like distribution of ancestral property, share of women in property, property rights of adopted children, etc., are complicated matters that vary according to the community, requiring careful interpretation and application of laws. The best course of action is always to consult a legal professional who specializes in matters of inheritance and succession.
Future Prospect for Civil Marriages in India Post Legal Reforms :
Civil marriage is a significant aspect of Indian society which provides a means for partners of diverse religious and cultural backgrounds to legalize their unions under a non-religious, legally sanctioned agreement. However, there are various areas of conflict that pose challenges for civil marriages in India. With the objective of resolving these conflicts, the Law Commission of India, in its 212th report, proposed several crucial reforms which could lead to positive changes for the future prospects of civil marriages in the country.
One of the most promising recommendations is the introduction of a uniform civil code. This could standardize the law applicable to all Indian citizens irrespective of their religious affiliations, facilitating equal rights for every individual under marriage, divorce, adoption, and maintenance. This proposed reform not only safeguards the constitutional mandate of equality but also reflects a progressive societal mindset, breaking religious and cultural barriers.
Moreover, the reforms also include essential revisions in the age of marriage, stressing the importance of maintaining an equal age for both genders as a significant stride towards achieving gender equality. The provisions related to divorce and alimony also offer a more gender-neutral perspective.
However, the proposed reforms have to overcome considerable societal and political resistance, and their success heavily relies on efficient implementation and public acceptance. Hence, effective strategies need to be adopted for a broader understanding and acceptance of these reforms in society. The implementation of these legal reforms for civil marriages proposed by the Law Commission could create an inclusive, equitable and just framework for all Indian citizens. However, its success would demand active collaboration between lawmakers, policymakers, and citizens to promote its understanding and acceptance across society.
Recommendation by Law Commission
The Law Commission of India, in its 212th Report titled Laws of Civil Marriages in India – A Proposal to Resolve Certain Conflicts, made significant recommendations concerning civil marriages in the country.
One of the key concerns raised by the commission was the absence of a provision that compels the registration of marriages in India, making the enforcement and verification of such marriages problematic. This lack of legislation does not only make it challenging to protect the rights of spouses, but also provides a loophole for the exploitation of women.
Consequently, the Law Commission recommended a mandatory registration of all marriages in the country. Such a move, it argued, would offer a higher level of legal protection to women, particularly regarding issues related to dowry and domestic violence.
The commission also raised concerns over certain discriminatory provisions in the current laws, particularly those that undermine gender equality. For instance, the age for marriage in India is set at 21 years for men and 18 years for women. The commission recommended a revision of these provisions to reflect an equal age for both men and women.
Moreover, it addressed the issue of religious conversions solely for the purpose of marriage. The Commission argued against such conversions, proposing a neutral civil marriage law that could potentially bring uniformity to the process and encourage inter-religious marriages without necessitating conversion.
Also, the commission recommended that the laws should accommodate various forms of family systems, given India’s diversity. These include monogamous, polygamous, joint and nuclear family systems. This will make the law more inclusive, thus encouraging more people to formally register their marriages.
Lastly, it recommended the standardization of procedures for marriage registration, including the process, documentation, witnesses and registration fees.
These recommendations by the Law Commission are envisioned to streamline the laws related to civil marriages in India, resolve potential conflicts and protect the rights of both parties involved. These proposals, if implemented, could pave the way for a more egalitarian and inclusive system that recognizes and respects India’s socio-cultural diversity
Conclusion :
The article focuses on the diverse nature of civil marriages in India and the pressing need to address the potential conflicts and complexities due to varying customs, traditions, and legal systems within the nation. It has stressed on the importance of creating a standardized civil code that can equally protect and cater to all citizens regardless of their religion or societal norms. Moreover, the article suggests how this might contribute towards fostering greater social harmony, unity, and respect for gender equality and human rights. This proposal for a universal civil code, therefore, can be viewed as an attempt to resolve disparities and contradictions and build a more inclusive society where all citizens are subjected to the same set of marital laws. The discussions by Law Commission of India further elucidate how creating a single legal system will help eradicate instances of polygamy and gender injustice and it reflects the intention to adopt a modernistic approach that places emphasis on human dignity and individual rights. Therefore, the primary inference from this proposal is that harmonizing civil marriage laws can help streamline the legal processes and promote a culture of fairness, equal treatment, and non-discrimination, besides ensuring easy enforcement of the law. However, it is necessary to ensure that any proposed uniform code be sufficiently flexible and adaptable to cater to the cultural diversity that is inherent within Indian society. The consideration of civil marriages in India calls for a paradigm shift in legal norms, reflecting the changing times and evolving societal expectations.
References :
- https://cdnbbsr.s3waas.gov.in/s3ca0daec69b5adc880fb464895726dbdf/uploads/2022/08/2022081096.pdf visited on 28/11/23.
- https://vakilsearch.com/blog/court-marriage-and-civil-marriage-differences/ visited on 28/11/23.
- https://www.advocatekhoj.com/library/lawreports/lawsofcivilmarriagesinindia/1.php?Title=Laws%20of%20Civil%20Marriages%20in%20India%20-%20A%20Proposal%20to%20Resolve%20certain%20Conflicts&STitle= visited on 29/11/23.
- https://indiankanoon.org/doc/196490855/ visited on 29/11/23.
- https://www.lawctopus.com/academike/inter-caste-inter-religious-marriages-social-legal-issues/ visited on 30/11/23.
- Special Marriage Act, 1954, No. 4 d, Acts of Parliament, 1954 (India).
- Special Marriage Act, 1954, No.2b, Acts of Parliament, 1954 (India).
- The Foreign Marriage Act, 1969, No. 3,4,18,27, Acts of Parliament, 1969 (India).
- Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872, No.04, Acts of Parliament, 1872 (Indian)
- https://www.advocatekhoj.com/library/lawreports/lawsofcivilmarriagesinindia/8.php?Title=Laws%20of%20Civil%20Marriages%20in%20India%20-%20A%20Proposal%20to%20Resolve%20certain%20Conflicts&STitle=Special%20Marriage%20Act%201954 visited on 13/12/2023.
- https://www.advocatekhoj.com/library/lawreports/lawsofcivilmarriagesinindia/10.php?Title=Laws%20of%20Civil%20Marriages%20in%20India%20-%20A%20Proposal%20to%20Resolve%20certain%20Conflicts&STitle=Under%20the%20Special%20Marriage%20Act%201872 visited on 13/12/2023.
- https://www.scribd.com/document/306361697/Law-Commission-Report-No-212-Laws-of-Civil-Marriages-in-India-a-Proposal-to-Resolve-Certain-Conflicts Visited on 13/12/2023.
- https://www.advocatekhoj.com/library/lawreports/lawsofcivilmarriagesinindia/14.php?Title=Laws%20of%20Civil%20Marriages%20in%20India%20-%20A%20Proposal%20to%20Resolve%20certain%20Conflicts&STitle=Recommendations visited on 15/11/23.
Disclaimer: The materials provided herein are intended solely for informational purposes. Accessing or using the site or the materials does not establish an attorney-client relationship. The information presented on this site is not to be construed as legal or professional advice, and it should not be relied upon for such purposes or used as a substitute for advice from a licensed attorney in your state. Additionally, the viewpoint presented by the author is of a personal nature.
0 Comments