This article is written by Anshika Tiwari of BBA LL.B (Hons.) of Government New Law College Indore Madhya Pradesh, an intern under Legal Vidhiya
Abstract
This abstract provides an overview of copyright protection for computer software in India, highlighting its importance in safeguarding intellectual property rights and fostering innovation. It covers the definition of computer software, copyright laws in India, eligible works for protection, scope of protection, ownership, duration, enforcement mechanisms, fair use exceptions, and challenges within the legal framework. The abstract concludes by emphasizing the significance of copyright protection for driving innovation in the software industry and outlines future trends for strengthening copyright laws in India.
Keywords
copyright protection, copyright protection in India, Copyright protection act, computer software, What is the law on copyright.
Introduction
Copyright protection for computer software in India is crucial for safeguarding the intellectual property rights of software developers and creators. Under the Indian Copyright Act of 1957,[1] computer software is considered a literary work, making it eligible for copyright protection. This protection extends to both source code and object code,[2] ensuring that creators have exclusive rights over their software, including reproduction[3], distribution, and adaptation.
In India, copyright protection is automatic upon the creation of the software, and registration with the Copyright Office is optional but recommended for added legal benefits. Copyright protection grants creators the exclusive right to reproduce[4], distribute, and modify their software, as well as the ability to enforce these rights against infringement.[5]
However, it’s essential for software developers and companies to understand the nuances of copyright law in India, including the limitations and exceptions to copyright protection, such as fair use and the idea-expression dichotomy. Additionally, with the rapid advancements in technology and the digital landscape, staying updated on copyright laws and regulations is imperative for effectively protecting software creations in India.
What is Computer Software?
Computer software is a programs and applications that run on computers or other electronic devices, including source code, object code, and executable files.[6] Computer software please a critical role in various industries and is subject to copyright protection.
Computer software is a program that permits a computer to perform a specific task, as opposed to the physical components of the system (hardware).[7] “This includes application software such as a word processor, which enables a user to perform a task, and system software such as an operating system, which permits other software to run correctly or properly, by interfacing with hardware and with other software”.[8]
What is Copyright?
Copyright is a legal right that protects original work of authorship, including computer software, from unauthorized copying and distribution.[9]
Copyright is a legal concept that provides creators with the exclusive right to use, reproduce, distribute, and monetize their original work. It offers protection to literary, artistic, musical, and other creative expressions. Copyright laws vary from country to country, and this topic will explore the basics of copyright law in India.
Copyright Law in India
India has a well-established copyright law framework that protects various forms of intellectual property.[10] The Copyright Act, 1957, governs copyright protection in the country. it is based on the principle that creators should have the right to control the use and dissemination of their work.
Eligible work for copyright protection
Under Indian copyright law several types of work are eligible for copyright protection. This include:
- “Literary works: Articles, books, computer software poems, manuscripts and more.
- Artistic works: Drawings, paintings, photographs, the sculptures, and architectural designs.
- Musical works: Original composition, music recordings and songs.
- Cinematography films: Auto visual works, including documentaries and movies.
- Sound recordings: Songs, music albums, and any recorded sounds.”[11]
How to Register Copyright?
- “Application has to be filed, detailing the ‘Source Code’ (kept confidential by Authority) and ‘Object Code’ (published by authority) along with evidence of name of the applicant, nationality evidence of the applicant, work description, address evidence or proof, copies of the work submitted, the date of publication of work.
- After filing the application, the authority circulates the source code in the diary.
- Source code is made seeable to the public for 30 days and if no objections are raised, the process continues further and in case of objections copyright hearing is taken.”[12]
- If accepted, the examiner will check the application for a mistake or an error and send a letter of discrepancies, if any, to the author or owner, and in case there are no errors in the application, the same is passed.
- “Where the work is confirmed or accepted by the registrar copyright notice is given on the copies of the work through the © (copyright) symbol.”[13]
Scope of Protection
The scope of protection under copyright law for computer software in India encompasses a range of exclusive rights that are granted to the copyright owner. These rights enable the owner to control how their software is used, reproduced, distributed, and adapted. Let’s explore into each aspect in more detail:
- Reproduction: Copyright protection grants the owner the exclusive right to reproduce the software in any form. This includes making copies of the software by downloading it from the internet, installing it onto a computer or other devices, and saving it onto storage media. Reproduction also covers activities such as compiling the source code[14] into object code or creating backup copies of the software.[15]
- Distribution: The copyright owner has the sole right to distribute copies of the software to the public. This includes selling physical copies of the software, such as CDs or DVDs, as well as distributing it electronically via the internet or other digital channels.[16] Distribution rights also extend to activities such as renting, leasing, or lending copies of the software to others.
- Adaptation: Copyright protection extends to adaptations or derivative works based on the original software. This includes making modifications, translations, or enhancements to the software, as well as creating new works that are based on the original code.[17] However, it’s important to note that creating an adaptation of software may require permission from the copyright owner, especially if it involves substantial changes or additions to the original work.
- Public Performance and Display: The copyright owner has the exclusive right to perform or display the software publicly.[18] This includes running the software on a computer screen for others to see, transmitting it over a network for remote access, or demonstrating its functionality at public events or trade shows. Public performance and display rights also cover activities such as showcasing screenshots or video demonstrations of the software online.
By exercising these exclusive rights, the copyright owner can control how their software is used and distributed in the marketplace. This not only allows them to protect their investment in creating the software but also incentivizes further innovation and development in the field.[19] Additionally, these rights enable the owner to generate revenue through licensing agreements, where they grant others permission to use the software in exchange for fees or royalties.
Copyright Ownership and Duration
Copyright protection in gives the creator, hold the person who has created the work, next exclusive rights to their creation.[20] However, copyright ownership can be transferred through agreements.
In general, copyright protection last for the lifetime of the author plus an additional 60 years after the author’s death. For works published anonymously, pseudonymously, or posthumously Copyright protection lasts for 60 years from the year of publication.[21]
Copyright Infringement And Remedies
Copyright infringement occurs when someone uses a copyrighted work without the permission of the original owner. In India, copyright infringement is a civil offence (crime). copyright owners have the right to take legal action against infringers to safeguard their rights and sick compensation for damages.
Common remedies for copyright infringement in India include:
- Injunction a court order to stop the infringer from using the copyrighted work immediately.[22]
- Damages: the copyright owner may claim appropriate damages resulting from the infringement.[23]
- Accounts and profits: The copyright owner may apply for an account of profits made by the infringer due to the infringement.
- Delivering of infringing copies: The court may order the infringer to deliver all copies of the copyrighted work to the copyright owner.
Fair Use And Exceptions
Indian copyright law also recognizes certain exceptions where copyrighted materials can be used without permission from the copyright owner. This exceptions are known as “fair dealing” or “fair use” provisions.[24] They allow limited and reasonable use of copyrighted works from purposes. They allow limited and reasonable use of copyrighted work for purposes such as research, review, criticism, education, news reporting, and more.[25]
It is important to note that fair use exceptions are subject to the specific conditions and should not unreasonably prejudice the legitimate interests of the copyright owner.
Importance of Copyright Protection for Computer Software
Copyright protection for computer software is essential for multiple reasons:
- Encouraging innovation: copyright protection incentivizes software developers to create new and innovative programs by granting them exclusive rights to there creations.[26] This encouraged investment in research and development, promoting technological advancements.
- Economic value: software represents a significant economic value, and copyright protection ensures that developers can maintain control over their creations. This promotes fair competition and allows developers to monetize their software through licensing or sales.
- Preventing unauthorized use: copyright protection helps deter individuals or entities from using or distributing software without authorization.[27] By enforcing copyright laws software developers can protect their work from unauthorized reproduction, reducing the risk of financial loss.
Legal Framework for Copyright Protection for Computer Software in INDIA
In India, copyright protection For computer software is governed by the Copyright Act 1957, and the copyright rules, 2013.[28] key provisions relevant to software copyright protection include
Originality: To be eligible for copyright protection, computer software must deflect originality and not be a mere copy of existing programs. Originality refers to the expression of an idea In a unique and creative manner.[29]
Literal and Non-Literal Elements: Copyright protection extends to port the little elements[30] source code, object code and non literal elements structure, sequence, and organization off computer software.
Copyright Ownership: In India, the author or creator of the software it’s considered the first owner of the copyright. However, if the software is created as part of employment, the employer is considered the first owner, unless there is an agreement stating otherwise.
Turn of Copyright: Copyright protection for computer software last for the lifetime of the author plus 60 years from the year of the authors.[31]
Infringement and Remedies: Copyright infringement occurs when someone violates the exclusive rights of the copyright. The remedies for copyright infringement include injunction, damages, add account of profits.[32]
Challenges
- Piracy: Software piracy remains a significant challenge in India, with unauthorized copies of software being widely available in the market.[33] This not only deprives software developers of rightful revenues but also undermines their ability to invest in research and development, ultimately stifling innovation.[34]
- Enforcement Issues: The enforcement of copyright laws can be challenging due to various factors such as limited resources, lengthy legal procedures, and a backlog of cases in the judicial system. As a result, many copyright infringement cases go unresolved, leading to a perception of impunity among infringers.
- Technological Advancements: The rapid pace of technological advancements poses new challenges for copyright protection. Technologies such as cloud computing, peer-to-peer file sharing, and virtualization make it easier to copy and distribute software without authorization, complicating enforcement efforts.
- Globalization: With the increasing globalization of the software industry, copyright issues often involve multiple jurisdictions, making enforcement more complex. Differences in copyright laws and enforcement mechanisms across countries can create legal loopholes that infringers exploit to evade liability.
Future Trends
- Digital Rights Management (DRM): One of the emerging trends in copyright protection is the use of digital rights management (DRM) technologies. DRM allows copyright owners to encrypt their software and control access to it through licensing agreements. While DRM can help deter piracy and unauthorized use, its effectiveness depends on the strength of encryption and the willingness of users to comply with licensing terms.[35]
- Licensing Agreements: Software developers are increasingly relying on licensing agreements to protect their intellectual property rights. These agreements specify the terms and conditions under which users are allowed to use the software, including restrictions on copying, distribution, and modification.[36] By entering into licensing agreements, copyright owners can enforce their rights more effectively and generate revenue through licensing fees or royalties.[37]
- Education and Awareness: Increasing awareness about the importance of intellectual property rights is crucial for addressing copyright infringement issues. Educational initiatives aimed at raising awareness among stakeholders, including software developers, consumers, and policymakers, can help foster a culture of respect for intellectual property rights and deter infringement.[38]
- Open-Source Software: The rise of open-source software presents both challenges and opportunities for copyright protection. While open-source licenses grant users broad freedoms to use, modify, and distribute the software, they also impose certain obligations, such as sharing modifications with the community.[39] Copyright owners of open-source software often rely on community-driven enforcement mechanisms to protect their rights and ensure compliance with license terms.[40]
- Collaborative Enforcement Efforts: Given the global nature of copyright infringement, collaborative enforcement efforts involving governments, industry associations, law enforcement agencies, and technology companies are essential for combating piracy effectively.[41] International cooperation and information sharing can help identify and prosecute infringers across borders, making it harder for them to evade accountability.
Conclusion
In conclusion, copyright protection plays a vital role in safeguarding the intellectual property rights of software developers and creators in India. By recognizing computer software as literary works under the Copyright Act of 1957, the law provides creators with exclusive rights over their software creations, including reproduction, distribution, and adaptation.
While copyright protection is automatic upon creation, registration with the Copyright Office offers additional legal benefits. It is crucial for software developers and companies to stay informed about copyright laws and regulations to effectively protect their software creations in the rapidly evolving digital landscape of India. Through robust copyright protection, India can foster innovation, encourage creativity, and ensure a thriving ecosystem for software development and technological advancement.
References
- https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
- https://vakilsearch.com/blog/copyrights-in-computer-programs-where-to-apply/ visited on 07/03/2024
- https://intellectual-property-helpdesk.ec.europa.eu/news-events/news/software-protection-india-copyright-or-patent-2023-12-13_ visited on 08/03/2024
- LEGAL PROTECTION FOR COMPUTER SOFTWARE IN INDIA https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/ visited on 08/03/2024
- https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Computer_software visited on 08/03/2024
- Essential Communication Strategies during Organizational https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/essential-communication-strategies-organisational visited on 08/03/2024
- https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/#:~:text=Visited on 09/03/2024
- https://www.researchgate.net/publication/301890434_Understanding_Copyright_Laws_Infringement_Protection_and_Exceptions visited on 09/03/2024
- https://www.sciencedirect.com visited on 10/03/2024
[1] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[2] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[3] https://www.sciencedirect.com visited on 10/03/2024
[4] https://www.sciencedirect.com visited on 10/03/2024
[5] https://vakilsearch.com/blog/copyrights-in-computer-programs-where-to-apply/ visited on 07/03/2024
[6] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[7] https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/#:~:text=Visited on 09/03/2024
[8] https://quizlet.com/619094769/software-concepts-flash-cards/ visited on 08/03/2024
[9] https://intellectual-property-helpdesk.ec.europa.eu/news-events/news/software-protection-india-copyright-or-patent-2023-12-13_ visited on 08/03/2024
[10] https://intellectual-property-helpdesk.ec.europa.eu/news-events/news/software-protection-india-copyright-or-patent-2023-12-13_ visited on 08/03/2024
[11]https://www.researchgate.net/publication/301890434_Understanding_Copyright_Laws_Infringement_Protection_and_Exceptions visited on 09/03/2024
[12] software-concepts-flash-cards/ visited on 08/03/2024
[13] legal-protection-for-computer-software visited on 09/03/2024
[14] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[15] https://www.sciencedirect.com visited on 10/03/2024
[16] https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Computer_software visited on 08/03/2024
[17] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[18] https://vakilsearch.com/blog/copyrights-in-computer-programs-where-to-apply/ visited on 07/03/2024
[19] Essential Communication Strategies during Organizational https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/essential-communication-strategies-organisational visited on 08/03/2024
[20] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[21] LEGAL PROTECTION FOR COMPUTER SOFTWARE IN INDIA https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/ visited on 08/03/2024
[22] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[23] https://vakilsearch.com/blog/copyrights-in-computer-programs-where-to-apply/ visited on 07/03/2024
[24] LEGAL PROTECTION FOR COMPUTER SOFTWARE IN INDIA https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/ visited on 08/03/2024
[25]https://www.researchgate.net/publication/301890434_Understanding_Copyright_Laws_Infringement_Protection_and_Exceptions visited on 09/03/2024
[26] https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Computer_software visited on 08/03/2024
[27] https://vakilsearch.com/blog/copyrights-in-computer-programs-where-to-apply/ visited on 07/03/2024
[28] https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/#:~:text=Visited on 09/03/2024
[29]LEGAL PROTECTION FOR COMPUTER SOFTWARE IN INDIA https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/ visited on 08/03/2024
[30] https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/#:~:text=Visited on 09/03/2024
[31] LEGAL PROTECTION FOR COMPUTER SOFTWARE IN INDIA https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/ visited on 08/03/2024
[32] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[33] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[34] Essential Communication Strategies during Organizational https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/essential-communication-strategies-organisational visited on 08/03/2024
[35] https://vakilsearch.com/blog/copyrights-in-computer-programs-where-to-apply/ visited on 07/03/2024
[36] LEGAL PROTECTION FOR COMPUTER SOFTWARE IN INDIA https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/ visited on 08/03/2024
[37] https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Computer_software visited on 08/03/2024
[38] https://intellectual-property-helpdesk.ec.europa.eu/news-events/news/software-protection-india-copyright-or-patent-2023-12-13_ visited on 08/03/2024
[39] https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Computer_software visited on 08/03/2024
[40] https://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/855/Indian-Copyright-Software.html visited on 07/03/2024
[41] https://www.proind.in/blog/legal-protection-for-computer-software-in-india/#:~:text=Visited on 09/03/2024
Disclaimer: The materials provided herein are intended solely for informational purposes. Accessing or using the site or the materials does not establish an attorney-client relationship. The information presented on this site is not to be construed as legal or professional advice, and it should not be relied upon for such purposes or used as a substitute for advice from a licensed attorney in your state. Additionally, the viewpoint presented by the author is of a personal nature.
